When someone turns 65 (or qualifies earlier due to disability), the question often arises: should you rely on Medicare health insurance, or continue (or switch to) a private health insurance plan? At Illinois Insurance Center, we speak plainly so you can make a confident choice. We don’t sell insurance ourselves—we shop over 20+ carriers to find a fit for you.
This post breaks down the differences, the pros and cons, and how to decide which path might work better for your health coverage needs.
What is Medicare Health Insurance?
Medicare is a federal health insurance program run by the U.S. government. It was created to help people age 65 or older, and some younger individuals with disabilities, pay for hospital care, doctor visits, and medical services.
Medicare has several “parts”:
- Part A (Hospital Insurance): Covers inpatient hospital stays, skilled nursing facility care, some home health services, and hospice care.
- Part B (Medical Insurance): Covers doctor visits, outpatient care, durable medical equipment (like walkers or wheelchairs), and some preventive services.
- Part D (Prescription Drug Coverage): Helps cover the cost of prescriptions. You pick a drug plan or enroll in one included in a Medicare Advantage plan.
- Medicare Advantage (Part C): Instead of Original Medicare, you choose a private-company plan that bundles Part A, Part B, and usually Part D, often with extra benefits.
- Medigap (Supplemental Insurance): Private policies that help pay some costs Medicare doesn’t cover (like coinsurance, copays, or deductibles).
You must sign up for Medicare (Parts A & B) typically around age 65, unless you qualify earlier due to disability. for Medicare are based on age, citizenship or residency, and work history (or your spouse’s work history) in many cases.
What is Private Health Insurance (Commercial Health Plans)?
Private health insurance refers to plans offered by insurance companies. These might include:
- Employer-sponsored group plans
- Plans you buy through the Health Insurance Marketplace (or state exchange)
- Individual and family plans on the open market
- Private Medicare supplement (Medigap) or Medicare Advantage plans
Private plans tend to have more flexibility in plan design, benefit choice, network structure, and sometimes extra services. But they also contrast with Medicare in costs, eligibility, benefit control, and more.
Key Differences of Medicare and Private Health Insurance
Here’s a comparison of Medicare health insurance vs. private health insurance to highlight how they differ in practice.
|
Feature
|
Medicare Health Insurance
|
Private Health Insurance
|
|
Who runs it / structure
|
Federal government program (CMS) + private insurers for parts (e.g. Part D, Medicare Advantage)
|
Private insurance companies (commercial)
|
|
Eligibility / sign up
|
Age 65 (or younger with qualifying disability), meeting citizenship/residency rules. You must sign up for Medicare during designated times.
|
Anyone who applies and is accepted (subject to underwriting rules or open enrollment). No fixed “eligibility by age.”
|
|
Coverage parts / structure
|
Part A + Part B (Original Medicare). Then you may add Part D or choose Medicare Advantage.
|
One plan typically bundles hospital, doctor, prescriptions, etc.
|
|
Cost sharing / out-of-pocket
|
You pay premiums (for Part B, sometimes Part A if not premium-free), deductibles, coinsurance. Some coverage gaps exist unless you supplement with Medigap or choose Advantage.
|
Premiums, deductibles, copays, coinsurance. Many plans also have an out-of-pocket maximum.
|
|
Network restrictions
|
Original Medicare lets you see any provider that accepts Medicare. Medicare Advantage often limits to network.
|
Private plans usually use networks (HMO, PPO, EPO) — out-of-network care may cost more or not be covered.
|
|
Extra benefits
|
Original Medicare covers many medically necessary services but often not routine dental, vision, hearing, or wellness extras. Some Medicare Advantage plans include extras.
|
Often include extras (dental, vision, wellness, etc.), depending on the plan.
|
|
Flexibility / customization
|
Less flexibility in altering core benefits. You choose between Original Medicare or Advantage and optional add-ons.
|
More plan options, tiers (bronze, silver, gold, platinum) with different benefit mixes, more flexibility to pick what you want.
|
|
Guaranteed issue
|
During certain enrollment periods, you can’t be denied when enrolling in Medicare.
|
Private plans can deny coverage (depending on rules) or charge more based on health status (though ACA rules limit this in many marketplaces).
|
|
Coordination if you already have private coverage
|
If you have private coverage at age 65, Medicare may become primary or secondary depending on your situation.
|
You usually keep the private policy entirely; Medicare may secondary if it is in effect.
|
|
Out-of-pocket limits
|
Original Medicare has no fixed annual out-of-pocket limit (Medigap or Advantage help impose limits).
|
Most private plans have a maximum you will pay in one year, after which the insurer pays 100%.
|
When people compare “Medicare health insurance vs private health insurance,” here are key trade-offs to consider:
Cost and predictability
- Private insurance may offer predictable cost sharing with a clear out-of-pocket maximum.
- Medicare (Original) has some unpredictable costs unless you supplement it.
- Medicare Advantage plans often include cost caps.
- Private plans may cost more in premiums, especially if you want wide coverage or extra features.
Provider access and networks
- Original Medicare allows access to virtually any provider that accepts Medicare (no network restriction).
- Private plans tend to use provider networks. If you go out of network, costs may rise sharply.
- Medicare Advantage often has more restrictions on which providers you can see.
Benefits beyond basic medical care
- Some private health coverage plans offer dental, vision, wellness, alternative therapies.
- Medicare Advantage plans sometimes bundle extra benefits, but Original Medicare doesn’t cover many of these extras.
- Private plans may tailor extra benefits better to your specific needs.
Health status and risk
- If a person has health issues, private plans may charge more (or deny coverage, depending on rules).
- Medicare eliminates or reduces risk of being denied due to preexisting conditions (during eligible enrollment periods).
- Over time, serious health needs might favor a plan with strong coverage and predictable limits.
Simplicity vs complexity
- Medicare’s structure is more fixed, so once you understand it, it’s simpler to compare your options.
- Private plans can vary widely, making comparisons more complex (different networks, benefit structures, cost sharing).
How to Decide: Which Approach Might Be Best?
Here’s how to think through your decision. Use this as a guide to talk it through with Illinois Insurance Center.
1. Check your eligibility for Medicare.
When will you qualify? Will you need to sign up? Are there penalties if you delay?
2. List your health needs and priorities.
What doctors or hospitals do you want access to? Do you need strong prescription coverage? Do you want extra benefits (vision, dental)?
3. Compare total costs (not just premiums).
Add up premiums, deductibles, copays, coinsurance, out-of-pocket maximums, and extra benefits.
4. Check provider networks.
Make sure the doctors and hospitals you want are included. With private plans, you might face high costs if you go out of network.
5. Factor in flexibility.
If you travel, move, or change health needs, you may prefer a plan that adapts.
6. Look at coordination if you already have private coverage.
If you already carry private health insurance, you’ll want to know how it works with Medicare. In many cases, private insurance may act as secondary, depending on the rules.
7. Let us help you compare options.
As a broker that shops 20+ carriers, Illinois Insurance Center can show you health coverage plans side by side — both Medicare-related and purely private — so you see what fits you best.
Why Use Illinois Insurance Center for this Comparison?
- Because Illinois Insurance Center doesn’t offer just one plan, we can compare Medicare health insurance and private health plans for you.
- We examine 20+ carriers to find the best match for your medical needs, budget, and provider preferences.
- We help you understand cost trade-offs, coverage gaps, and benefits you care about.
- We guide you through sign up timelines, eligibility issues, and plan transitions.
We’re not tied to just one insurer — so we work for you.
Contact Illinois Insurance Center
Ready to see side-by-side quotes for Medicare and private health coverage plans? Contact us at (708) 524-4900 or visit our Contact page. Let us help you pick the health plan that fits your life — whether it’s Medicare, private insurance, or a mix of both.
Also, if you live in one of our service areas, check out our Areas We Serve page to confirm coverage in your region.
FAQs about Medicare Insurance
Q: When can you sign up for Medicare?
A: You generally have a 7-month initial enrollment window: 3 months before your 65th birthday, the month you turn 65, and 3 months after. If you miss that window, there are special and general enrollment periods—but you might face penalties.
Q: What happens if you delay Part B?
A: You may pay a lifetime late enrollment penalty, unless you have other creditable coverage.
Q: Can you have Medicare and private insurance at the same time?
A: Yes. In many cases, one acts as primary, the other as secondary. But coordination of benefits rules apply.
Q: What is the difference between Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage?
A: Original Medicare is Parts A & B, and you can add Part D or Medigap. Medicare Advantage (Part C) is a bundled alternative offered by private insurers, often including drug coverage and extra benefits.
Q: Will private health insurance still be useful after age 65?
A: It can be. Some people keep private plans (employer or retiree group plans) alongside Medicare. Or they may choose private plans instead of Medicare, if eligible. But you’ll need to compare benefits, cost, and rules.
